* Reason for retorquing: Are you retorquing because the engine is new and requires a second torque sequence (as specified in the manual)? Or are you doing it because of a potential head gasket leak, overheating, or other problem that *might* indicate head bolt stretching? The former is often necessary; the latter is more complex.
* Engine's history: Has the engine experienced overheating or any significant mechanical issues? Overheating can cause head gasket failure and warp the head, rendering retorquing ineffective or even damaging.
* Type of head bolts: Are they standard bolts or studs? Stretching is a greater concern with standard bolts. Studs are generally reusable.
* Head gasket condition: A damaged head gasket may require a complete head gasket replacement, not just retorquing. Retorquing a compromised head gasket could damage it further.
* Your mechanical skill: Are you comfortable with the precision required for properly retorquing head bolts? Incorrect torque can lead to head gasket failure or even cracked cylinder heads.
In short:
* If the engine is new and a second torque sequence is specified in the service manual, then YES, you absolutely should re-torque the head bolts. This is a crucial part of the break-in process.
* If the engine is old and you suspect a problem (leak, overheating), then NO, you probably shouldn't just re-torque the head bolts without a thorough investigation. You need to determine the root cause of the problem. Simply retorquing may mask a more serious issue requiring head gasket replacement, head machining, or even more extensive repair. This should be done by someone experienced in engine repair.
Always consult the engine's service manual for the correct procedure and torque specifications. Improper retorquing can lead to serious engine damage. If you are unsure, seek the help of a qualified mechanic.